For many people, money is not primarily a math problem.  It’s a nervous-system problem.  A meaning-making problem.  A relationship problem.  Plenty of capable adults avoid budgets, dodge bank statements, and feel a low-grade dread when they open an app.  They may “know” what to do, but still struggle to do it consistently.  That gap is where psychology lives.

When it comes to money and finances, context matters.  In a high-pressure economy, money is not only a personal responsibility topic, it’s also a power topic.  Many people are not “bad with money.”  They are underpaid, overexposed to marketing, and carrying stress that never fully resolves.  This article stays close to the individual experience, while keeping one eye open to the systemic realities that shape avoidance, denial, and despair.  It also validates what couples and families already know: money rarely stays inside one person’s private mind.  It moves through the whole system.

A client of mine was a pretty successful professional, with a growing business and good prospects.  Despite his success, he really struggled to talk about finances with his fiancé.  In a particularly stressful conversation about retirement, he blurted out “But 30 million isn’t what it used to be!”  This threw me off because they hadn’t really ever said how much they had or planned to have.  In the moment, we were able to name that money and lifestyle is relative, and that fear around money can be true for any social class.

Common questions people ask when money feels stressful

• “Why do I avoid looking at my bank account?”
• “Why does budgeting make me feel ashamed or panicky?”
• “Why can’t I stick to a plan, even when I want to?”
• “Is money stress affecting my relationship more than I realize?”
• “Can therapy actually help with money anxiety, overspending, or avoidance?”

Why budgeting can feel impossible, even when you want it

1) Avoidance is a coping strategy, not a character flaw

Avoidance often shows up when money reliably triggers shame, fear, or helplessness.  The brain learns: “If I look, I will feel awful.”  So you don’t look.  That is not laziness.  It is negative reinforcement doing its job.

Over time, avoidance becomes expensive.  Fees accumulate, decisions get delayed, and anxiety grows.  The irony is that the thing you avoid to reduce distress becomes the thing that increases distress.  Avoidance tends to soften when it is treated as protection rather than pathology.  In therapy, the goal is not to force a sudden deep-dive into every number.  It’s to make “looking” tolerable again, in doses that don’t overwhelm your system.

What this can look like in therapy

• Mapping the avoidance loop: trigger → emotion/body response → avoidance behavior → short-term relief → long-term cost.
• Building regulation skills that reduce the threat response (grounding, pacing, breath, orienting).
• Practicing graded exposure to money tasks, scaled to your tolerance (one login, one statement, one category, then stop).

2) Shame turns practical tasks into identity threats

Budgets are supposed to be neutral.  For many people, they are not.  They feel like a referendum on competence, maturity, or worth.  Shame creates a particular trap: it makes you want to hide, and hiding prevents learning.  When shame is driving, even simple tasks can feel like stepping into a spotlight.

Therapy can help separate identity from behavior.  “I’m irresponsible” becomes “I’m overwhelmed,” “I’m avoiding,” or “I’m scared.”  That shift matters, because behavior change becomes possible when you are not defending your worth.  Shame also tends to thrive in secrecy, and therapy is one place where the truth can be spoken without collapse.  (Brown, 2012.)

So many of my clients have struggled with debt, and often not because they don’t have income.  Most of them with this kind of shame were raised in a situation where debt was part of life, and even when they now have enough money to not live in debt (often tens of thousands in credit card debt), they struggle to imagine being “good enough” to be debt free.

What this can look like in therapy

• Naming shame language and converting it into specific, workable descriptions.
• Exploring the cost of secrecy and the relief that can come with shared reality.
• Practicing self-compassion that is concrete rather than sentimental: “What would I say to someone I respect in the same situation?”

3) Scarcity narrows attention and bandwidth

Scarcity is not only “not enough money.”  Scarcity is “not enough margin.”  Not enough time, sleep, childcare, emotional energy, or stability.  When you are under strain, the brain prioritizes immediate relief over long-range planning.  This is a normal cognitive response to pressure.  The “present bias” described in behavioral economics is not a personal defect; it is often a predictable outcome of stress and uncertainty.  (Kahneman, 2011.)

Therapy can help you differentiate between a motivation problem and a bandwidth problem.  That distinction reduces self-attack, and it changes the plan.  If your life is already at maximum load, a workable approach often involves simplifying expectations, reducing decision fatigue, and building supports that are realistic for your actual constraints.

What this can look like in therapy

• Helping you name the “scarcity stack” (time + sleep + stress + money) rather than isolating money as the sole problem.
• Building micro-plans that are designed for low bandwidth.
• Supporting boundary-setting and realistic “good enough” decisions when perfection is not possible.

4) Anxiety and depression distort your sense of agency

Anxiety can push you into hypervigilance: “If I make one mistake, everything collapses.”  Depression can push you into resignation: “It doesn’t matter what I do.”  Either state makes financial planning harder, because planning requires a workable belief in the future.  In this sense, money management is partly mood-sensitive.  Not because feelings should dictate reality, but because feelings shape what your brain can access.

When mood improves, agency often returns.  Therapy can treat the anxiety spiral (catastrophic thinking, threat scanning, control behaviors) and the depressive spiral (hopelessness, shutdown, avoidance).  As those soften, financial planning becomes more thinkable.

A client of mine was very aware of how much money (to the penny) was in each account of theirs.  They checked most accounts twice a day.  They rationalized this as being on top of things, but more often than not it led to increased worry and – when money was in the red – increased reminders of their lack of control over their own situation.

What this can look like in therapy

• Working with catastrophic predictions: testing them, narrowing them, and building realistic contingency plans.
• Addressing learned helplessness with small, repeatable actions that rebuild agency.
• Strengthening emotional tolerance so money decisions are less reactive.

5) Executive function challenges quietly sabotage consistency

Some people struggle with budgeting for reasons that look like “motivation,” but are actually about planning, working memory, task initiation, and organization.  ADHD, chronic stress, sleep deprivation, and trauma history can all impair executive functioning.  You can care deeply and still struggle to follow through.  When this is the driver, the solution is usually fewer “big plans” and more structural support: automation, reminders, simplification, and systems that require less willpower.

Therapy can help you design money routines that match your brain.  Not the brain you wish you had on a perfect week, but the brain you reliably bring to your actual life.

What this can look like in therapy

• Designing friction-reducing routines: fewer categories, fewer decisions, and more automation.
• Building cue-based habits: pairing money tasks with an existing routine (for example, after Sunday coffee).
• Addressing the emotional layer that can make task initiation feel threatening, not merely hard.

6) Money carries family scripts, and those scripts are sticky

People inherit money beliefs long before they inherit money skills.  Messages like “We don’t talk about money,” “Debt is normal,” “Spending proves love,” or “Saving is selfish” can live in the background for decades.

These scripts tend to intensify under stress, and they show up in relationships.  One partner manages anxiety by controlling spending.  The other manages shame by avoiding numbers.  Both may be trying to protect the relationship, while accidentally escalating conflict.  Therapy helps couples and individuals locate the script, not just the symptom.  When partners can say, “This is what money meant in my house,” conflict often becomes more understandable and less personal.

What this can look like in therapy

• Family-of-origin exploration of money patterns (including the role money played in conflict, secrecy, or caretaking).
• Translating conflict from accusation into vulnerability (“I’m scared,” “I feel judged,” “I feel out of control”).
• Creating agreements that account for differing risk tolerance and different definitions of “security.”

7) Capitalism reliably manufactures dissatisfaction

Even with excellent habits, many people are fighting a constant headwind: targeted advertising, buy-now-pay-later convenience, algorithmic comparison, and a culture that treats consumption as identity.  When you feel behind, spending can become an attempt to feel “caught up,” “safe,” or “seen.”  Naming this is not an excuse.  It is a reality check.  If the environment is designed to keep you activated, your plan has to include nervous-system support and boundaries, not just spreadsheets.

Therapy can help you notice what gets activated in you: comparison, scarcity, loneliness, the urge for relief.  From there, you can build choice points and boundaries that reduce impulsive coping.

So many clients have engaged in “retail therapy” to help distract them from the things or people in their present moment.  The idea being that the good feeling “hit” we get with a new thing will last because we found a deal, bought something useful, or just engaged in “treat yourself.”  And the more tired or lonely or anxious we are, the more susceptible we are to this myth.

What this can look like in therapy

• Identifying emotional triggers for spending: fatigue, loneliness, resentment, and comparison.
• Strengthening distress tolerance and alternative regulation strategies.
• Values-consistent boundary work: reducing exposure to marketing and comparison funnels that reliably destabilize you.

When the problem is not “you”

If you are working hard and still cannot get ahead, it is reasonable to feel angry, discouraged, or exhausted.  Some financial stress is structural: housing costs, healthcare costs, childcare costs, debt burdens, wage stagnation, discrimination, and the “always on” pressure of modern work.

A budget can clarify reality, but it cannot fix a broken system.  Therapy cannot fix capitalism.  What therapy can do is help you stay connected to yourself, to your relationships, and to your agency inside a difficult environment.  That is not small.

If money has become a source of chronic dread or conflict, consider this a sign to take it seriously, with support.  Not because you are failing.  Because this is one of the most emotionally charged parts of modern life, and you deserve tools that meet the real problem.

Written by: Daniel Stillwell, Ph.D., LMFT

Daniel Stillwell (he/him) is the Clinical Director and a Marriage and Family Therapist (MFT) at the South Asheville branch of Matone Counseling. He has an LMFT in North Carolina and is a nationally credentialed (AAMFT) MFT supervisor. After receiving his masters in MFT from Louisville Seminary, he went on to earn a PhD in Family Therapy from Saint Louis University. He has practiced on and off since 2008, spending several years also as a professor of MFT for different universities. His passions for client care and organizational leadership are a great match for Matone Counseling and he has been delighted to be a part of the team since 2019.

:

References:

Brown, B. (2012). Daring greatly: How the courage to be vulnerable transforms the way we live, love, parent, and lead. Gotham Books.
Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, fast and slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Stanley, T. J., & Danko, W. D. (1996). The millionaire next door: The surprising secrets of America’s wealthy. Longstreet Press.