Queer and Nontraditional Relationships: What Makes Therapy Helpful?
Imagine you make an appointment with a therapist because someone close to you died. In the first session, you mention that you’re in an open relationship. Your therapist hasn’t worked with consensual nonmonogamy before and starts asking about jealousy, how you decided to open the relationship, and what agreements you have with your partners.
But you came in because you’re grieving.
I often talk with therapists who want to work well with queer and nontraditional relationships and feel unsure where to start. One of the first things I ask is what the person came to therapy for. Sometimes a relationship is where they’re hurting. Sometimes their partners are the people helping them get through it.
What Do I Mean by Queer and Nontraditional Relationships?
I use the phrase queer and nontraditional relationships to describe one of my specialties at Matone. Some people use queer as a broad term for their sexual orientation or gender identity, sometimes alongside words like lesbian, bisexual, trans, or nonbinary. Others prefer different language or are uncomfortable with the word queer. I use the words people choose for themselves.
Nontraditional can describe many ways of arranging relationships. Consensual nonmonogamy (CNM) describes relationships in which the people involved agree that they can have romantic, sexual, or other intimate connections with more than one person. You may also hear ethical nonmonogamy (ENM), a term that emphasizes consent and honesty.
Polyamory usually describes having, or being open to, more than one romantic or loving relationship. For some people, an open relationship means they can have sex with other people. For others, it also includes dating or forming other romantic relationships. Relationship anarchy is an approach to making commitments in each relationship without assuming, for example, that romantic partners automatically come before close friends.
There’s some overlap in how people use these terms. Someone can be straight and polyamorous, queer and monogamous, or both queer and polyamorous. If you tell me you’re in an open relationship, I’ll still need to ask what being open means to you and your partners.
What We Might Talk About in Therapy
When I was training to work with families, it was common to have four, five, or even seven people in a session. I enjoyed that work. I liked paying attention to how people made decisions together, who spoke up when something felt unfair, and who stepped in when a conversation got tense.
When I began working with polyamorous relationships and larger networks of partners, I found myself paying attention to many of the same things. You might be trying to figure out how to divide time when everyone needs more of it, what your partner meant when they made a promise, or how to talk about jealousy before it comes out in an argument. You might want to talk through whether to bring your partner to a family gathering and what it would feel like if they were introduced as a friend.
There are several ways to have those conversations in therapy. You might come on your own to talk through a relationship concern, or it might make sense for more than one partner to attend. Who comes depends on what you want help with, who wants to take part, and what feels safe to discuss together. If we decide that meeting separately would help, we’ll talk about how confidentiality works before we do it.
There’s still the question of if a nontraditional relationship is a good idea for many folks. While each situation is unique, I’ll at least say that in a review of 35 studies with more than 24,000 participants, Anderson and colleagues (2026) found that people in monogamous and nonmonogamous relationships reported similar levels of relationship satisfaction on average. In therapy, I want to hear how those relationships are going for you and for the people close to you.
Consent and Agreements
In consensually nonmonogamous relationships, partners may make agreements about what kinds of connections they’re comfortable with, what they want to know about other relationships, and what they can expect from one another. One person might think they’ve agreed to share plans before a first date. Their partner might remember agreeing to talk about it afterward. A conversation in therapy can help each person say what they thought they agreed to and decide what they want to do going forward.
Sometimes the problem is that someone broke a clear agreement or felt pressured to go along with one in the first place. I want to know whether everyone had room to say what they wanted, whether they felt free to say no, and what happened when they disagreed. Some people come in wanting to repair trust after infidelity or another breach of an agreement. Others want help deciding what they’re willing to agree to now.
What to Look For in a Therapist
In a recent Raindrops on Roses conversation with Kimberly Matone, we talked about how much there can be for therapists to learn about queer and nontraditional relationships. Part of our job is to do enough of that learning on our own that you can spend your time in therapy talking about your life. Your therapist may still ask what a term means to you or how an agreement works in your relationship. Those questions should help them understand what you’re there to talk about.
In a study of 249 people in consensually nonmonogamous relationships, Schechinger and colleagues (2018) found that how clients described their therapist’s approach was linked to how helpful they found therapy and whether they ended it early. Participants valued therapists who knew about nonmonogamy, listened without judgment, and could talk about their relationships without assuming those relationships were the source of their problems.
If you’re looking for a therapist, you can ask, “What experience do you have working with people in relationships like mine?” If you’re thinking about coming in with partners, you can also ask how the therapist decides who attends and how they handle confidentiality when people meet separately. Listen for whether they can answer plainly and seem interested in what you want help with.
Sometimes we’ll spend a lot of time talking about your relationships. Sometimes I’ll want to know who’s been checking in on you or who you can call when you get home. If you came in to talk about someone you lost, we can start there.
Raindrops on Roses – Episode 12: Most People Are Fundamentally Good
Most people are fundamentally good
In this episode of Raindrops on Roses, Dr. Daniel Stillwell, LMFT (Clinical Director of Matone Counseling’s South Asheville location) joins us to talk about the latest developments at Matone Counseling!
Tune in to hear about:
- The Matone Institute & upcoming intern/supervision programs
- Clinical work with queer and non-traditional relationships
- Insights on new parenthood and why “most people are fundamentally good”
Written by: Daniel Stillwell, Ph.D., LMFT
Daniel Stillwell (he/him) is the Clinical Director and a Marriage and Family Therapist (MFT) at the South
Asheville branch of Matone Counseling. He has an LMFT in North Carolina and is a nationally credentialed (AAMFT) MFT supervisor. After receiving his masters in MFT from Louisville Seminary, he went on to earn a PhD in Family Therapy from Saint Louis University. He has practiced on and off since 2008, spending several years also as a professor of MFT for different universities. His passions for client care and organizational leadership are a great match for Matone Counseling and he has been delighted to be a part of the team since 2019.
References and Further Reading
Anderson, J. R., Hinton, J. D. X., Bondarchuk-McLaughlin, A., Rosa, S., Tan, K. J., & Moor, L. (2026). Countering the monogamy-superiority myth: A meta-analysis of the differences in relationship satisfaction and sexual satisfaction as a function of relationship orientation. The Journal of Sex Research, 63(1), 130–142.
Fern, J. (2020). Polysecure: Attachment, trauma and consensual nonmonogamy. Thorntree Press.
Kardos, E. (2016). Relationship agreements: A simple and effective guide for strengthening communication, reducing conflict, and increasing intimacy to design your ideal relationship. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.
Rickert, E., & Zanin, A. (2026). The new more than two: A philosophical reimagining of the classic nonmonogamy guide. Thornapple Press.
Schechinger, H. A., Sakaluk, J. K., & Moors, A. C. (2018). Harmful and helpful therapy practices with consensually non-monogamous clients: Toward an inclusive framework. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 86(11), 879–891.


